I have spent much of today reading Robin Hobb's The Golden Fool, book two in the Tawny Man trilogy. And in some ways it has made me despair, because her writing is so darned good, her plot so cleverly woven, her characters so complete. I read the smoothly flowing scenes and wonder if anything my foolish hands can type or pen will ever be so much as a quarter of Hobb's incredible skill. Such thought I occasionally have while reading Pratchett, too.
I wonder what it is I am lacking. Is it the years of experience both writers have over me? Is it nothing to do with time and more to do with study of humans and humanity? Is it that they have spent time and effort in researching and observing, watching and listening, that I have so far done little of? Is it obvious, what I have not seen, that people react in particular ways?
I read of Sam Vimes and FitzChivalry Farseer and Susan Sto Helit and Althea Vestrit and the Fool and Carrot and Rincewind and all of them, and of course I know real people with different personalities. I see how my brother acts different around friends than he does around me. I know how things people say and do affect my own thoughts and reactions. Yet I find it difficult conveying any truly human character when I write.
I wrote a fanfiction recently, or rather, part of one. It was based around the Tribe season 1, which I had stumbled upon after years. I inserted a character into it, who was based largely on me, and even then I had great difficulty making her, or any other character, seem real. The closest I could get to even writing a character as they appeared in the series was Jack, and more because of his nervousness and speech impediment and the fact that of all the characters I remembered him the best from when I watched the show on TV many years ago. The next closest I got was Lex, but then I see him now as quite a shallow character, as much, I think, as a result of poor characterisation as because his character is written to be one-sided and manipulative. Even with a fanfiction, where I did not have to conjure up any more characters than the one I inserted, I found creating a character-driven plot difficult. Perhaps I based my fanfic too closely on the events of the first half of season one which I changed, rather than the way the characters reacted. I wanted to plot to move a certain way, though I knew I was pushing certain barriers which I knew even then were stretching the characters beyond their personalities in the series.
What I'm trying to convey is this: I am confused. I don't know whether to give in to my semi-romantic wanderings (and I mean that not in terms of love-romance, but in the way that pirates and highwaymen and Robin Hood are romantic), or to let the characters pick their own path, which in my experience have resulted in dead ends and abandonned manuscripts.
I try to build up characters. I try to make them real. And then I try to bend them against that which makes them real to satisfy my own yearning for the story. It is too long and complicated to give an example of this, and besides I am tired, but my romanticising has gone far beyond changing just one element of the plot to include what I have always called in my head the "mercy factor" - when one likeable character had opportunity and reason to kill another likeable character but did not. It's the reason the third Harry Potter book has always been my favourite of the seven; why of all the David Gemmell books I own, Hero in the Shadows, featuring the character Waylander, is the one I have always gone back to (and indeed features in one of my art A-level coursework pieces). It is why I squee and grin foolishly and clutch my squirming hands under my chin at films in which such a scene appears. It is part of the reason I like the (now complete) webcomic Inverloch by Sarah Ellerton (www.seraph-inn.com) so much. And so too do I love to write such scenes, and especially to start with them, and I plan for them later in the story and work out which characters and how, and add characters to make more such scenes possible when in reality all I am doing is making the story one long stream of mercy factor scenes and build-ups and hints of more to come, which while being what I enjoy writing, what I thrive upon, is diminishing the story and demeaning the characters I had built up.
Is it something lacking in me, that I try to create such situations for my characters? Am I a lost cause to sensible and logical writing, unable after so long to backtrack to more simple observations of true humanity, rather than my own romantic dreaming? I know how clichéd the mercy factor scenes I push for are, and yet even that does not stop me. Yet clichéd they are, for why would someone spare another's life in such situations as I have put them: in one, the character threatened has killed friends and comrades of the other, has himself injured her, and besides that is of the country at war with her's. She has caught him sneaking around where he should not be, yet allows him time enough to explain, apologise, flatter and convince her, and finally she spares him, slightly resentfully, and very much against her character - normally she is impulsive, quick to anger and to act, and slow to listen or to consider what is right and what is wise. Yet in this situation her adversary's words get through to her as those of her friends and family never did, and she listens and does what is right rather than what she desires. Can such a thing be explained away by implying she has changed, or acts differently around this other character? Does it deserve such treatment?
Would it, then, be better to forget for now the entire story and begin anew, from the very beginning. Can I, should I, unlearn what I already consider is right and relearn how to create a character, and how a plot is formed? Is it better to let this story finally lay to rest after two years of prodding and poking, and work on something completely new? Instead should I foresake writing anything of any length for the time being, as I begin my studies at university, and instead concentrate on that, on real life and real people instead of a world I have created and characters I build only to alter and put into the situations I dream about?
I have now been writing this post for well over an hour. Allowing my thoughts to flow freely in this manner has been liberating, but also sobering. It began with the simple issue of creating believable characters, and turned into a question I must ask myself: is it worth creating believable characters if I force them into situations in which I make them act out of character? I know I have always had the ambition to ber published, yet now I realise that something so lofty comes only with writing deserving of it, and mine certainly isn't. Is it, then, worth continuing for my own enjoyment when I know it will come to nothing, and the enjoyment eventually diminish because of that, or should I stop before such becomes too painful and put the same passion into something else: my university studies, perhaps, or some other hobby?
I know I spend too much time day dreaming. I always have. Even when my mind was not on a specific story I was writing, I fantacised about situtions in my own life which I know would never happen. Celebrities I had crushes on being suddenly and inexplicably wanted by the police and for no better reason than that I had written a fan letter, coming to me for shelter. People from the past appearing, confused and out of place, near my home, and I emplaining to such a person about cars and planes and TVs, and hearing about thousand-year-old legends as recent news or the gossip of a long dead King's court. Situations in which I was on the run, and working out where I could hide, how I could prevent authorities from discovering my whereabouts, how I would survive. I put myself into TV shows - Prison Break, for one - and told the characters, as if they were real people, things which seemed so obvious to me, who had seen the other side of the show, the bit outside Fox River because that was how the thing was written. And yet all too often I put myself in situations and imagined myself doing things I would never truly do. If confronted with a strange man speaking old English and wearing strange clothes I am more likely to look strangely at him and hurry away than talk to him and introduce to him the world he had stepped into. When my parents are away, as they are now, I imagine plane crashes and terrorist attacks and natural disasters which result in their deaths, and allow myself to get worked up, as even now, typing such a thing, gets me upset, imagining life without them. I wonder how other negative things, less tragic, would affect me: if a burglar entered my house, if I was involved in a car crash, if I was arrested because my fingerprints were somewhere (fingerprints which theorettically are no longer in the police database - they were taken months ago when the cafe I worked in was broken into, and I was promised they would be removed within three months). And I let myself get stressed, and upset, and am thereafter withdrawn and restless.
And now it is 11:20 at night, and I have made myself feel ill and unhappy once again. I am certain I will not sleep for another hour at least, and even then only after completing the book I am reading. My bedroom, so small when I moved into it from a larger room, now feels to large. And in truth it is, compared to my boyfriend's bedroom, and those of my closest friends. But somehow, dispite the clutter and the mess and how I have covered my walls and filled my room with my computer desk and my bookshelf, it seems so large and empty as it never did before, and I so lonely in it while my parents are so far away, and my boyfriend today so busy getting ready for uni, as I should have been today too.
Now I just feel emo, and there's no excuse for it. It's my own fault I have not attempted any social contact today, not even to eat supper with my brother or turn on the radio.
I don't know why I still write, so late into the night, when all thoughts have turned from writing to self pity and self loathing. I will stop now.